Paul’s Live from New York Pizza logo

Paul’s Live from New York Pizza

3 locations in California

In its own words: “Come in and try the best pizza in CA!”

Paul’s Live from New York Pizza people and owners

ANGEL MARIE AMATOLicensee, AMATO ANGEL MARIEper the register

Published by a third-party source · confirmed Nov 17, 2026, 7:41 PM UTC

PAUL GAETANO AMATOLicensee, AMATO ANGEL MARIEper the register

Published by a third-party source · confirmed Nov 17, 2026, 7:41 PM UTC

Contact Paul’s Live from New York Pizza

Contact forms

Contact form: https://www.paulslfnypizza.com/

Directly observed · confirmed Nov 17, 2026, 7:38 PM UTC · paulslfnypizza.com

Contact form: https://www.paulslfnypizza.com/contact/

Directly observed · confirmed Nov 17, 2026, 7:38 PM UTC · paulslfnypizza.com

Job application: https://www.paulslfnypizza.com/jobs/

Directly observed · confirmed Nov 17, 2026, 7:38 PM UTC · paulslfnypizza.com

Full contact-form data (JSON)

Paul’s Live from New York Pizza jobs

Careers page
Hiring evidence

Paul’s Live from New York Pizza locations

Paul’s Live from New York Pizza has 3 known locations in California, including Eureka, Fortuna and Arcata.

Loading location map…

Food service permit on file for 2 of 3 stores, all current. Liquor licence on file for 3 of 3 stores, all current.

  • EurekaLiquor licence 00514955, in force when read604 F St, Eureka, CA, 95501Run by AMATO ANGEL MARIE
  • FortunaLiquor licence 00597636, in force when read101 12th Street, CA, 95540Run by AMATO ANGEL MARIE
  • ArcataLiquor licence 00559534, in force when read665 Samoa Blvd, CA, 95521Run by AMATO ANGEL MARIE

Paul’s Live from New York Pizza menu and prices

Menu at Eureka

84 menu items, including Antipasto Salad, Large Dinner Salad and Garden Salad.

Online ordering prices: Antipasto Salad (Large): $21.58 on DoorDash Storefront (order.online); Large Dinner Salad: $11.98 on DoorDash Storefront (order.online).

Median price difference versus the website menu. At Eureka, 604 F St.
Menu sourceMedian differenceMatched items
DoorDash26%12
DoorDash Storefront (order.online)26%12
Pricing details

Every channel: Entrees & Pasta does not resolve to this place, so this is a difference against its published prices rather than what this branch charges directly. No evidence ties this menu to the selected location. Read from this location's own store object.

  • Channel prices at Eureka, 604 F St
    • DoorDash vs the site's own menu

      item differences +12.4% to +36.4%; 163 the site's own menu items unmatched

    • DoorDash Storefront (order.online) vs the site's own menu

      item differences +12.4% to +36.4%; 163 the site's own menu items unmatched

    the site's own menu: 189 items (32 priced) · DoorDash: 65 items (25 priced) · DoorDash Storefront (order.online): 53 items (25 priced)

    • Grubhubsearched, not found · 0/3 locations
    • Uber Eatssearched, not found · 0/3 locations
    • DoorDashmenu read · 2/3 locations
    • DoorDash Storefront (order.online)menu read · 2/3 locations
    • SpotHoppersearched, not found · 0/3 locations

    Derived from observations · confirmed Nov 17, 2026, 7:41 PM UTC

Dishes and prices

Resolved for Eureka. 84 dishes across 17 menus; the first 12 are shown here.

Paul’s Live from New York Pizza, Paul’s Double-Crusted Specialty Pizzas, Paul’s Specialty Pizzas, Pizza Rolls, Calzones, Salads, Entrees & Pasta, Garlic Bread & Garlic Knots, Hot Sandwiches, Appetizers, Wings & Tenders, On the Side, Dessert, Menu — not confirmed as this location's menu
DoorDash — could not be read

Paul’s Double-Crusted Specialty Pizzas

Double-Crusted Specialty Pizzas

The BrooklynDouble crusted pie filled with sautéed spinach, garlic, ricotta & mozzarella.Paul’s Double-Crusted Specialty Pizzas$28.75
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
Double-Crusted Specialty Pizzas
The BrooklynPaul’s Double-Crusted Specialty Pizzas$36.25
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The BrooklynPaul’s Double-Crusted Specialty Pizzas$49.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu

Paul’s Specialty Pizzas

The VegetarianTraditional pizza with tomato, yellow onion, garlic & broccoliPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$13.49
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The VegetarianPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$14.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The VegetarianPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$21.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The VegetarianPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$36.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The VegetarianPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$47.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The B.L.TA ranch based pizza with fresh spinach, bacon, tomato & mozzarellaPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$16.00
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
May be the same dish as “The B.L.T.”.
The B.L.TPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$18.25
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The B.L.TPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$25.75
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The B.L.TPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$33.25
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
Show 24 more dishes

Paul’s Specialty Pizzas

Specialty Pizzas

Rumble in d'BronxTraditional pizza w/ bacon, pineapple, and jalapeno...Paul’s Specialty Pizzas$16.00
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
Specialty Pizzas
Rumble in d'BronxPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$18.25
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
Rumble in d'BronxPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$25.75
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
Rumble in d'BronxPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$33.25
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
Rumble in d'BronxPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$47.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The New AmsterdamTraditional pizza w/ Italian sausage, mushroom, pepperoni, and yellow onions.Paul’s Specialty Pizzas$17.00
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
Specialty Pizzas
The New AmsterdamPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$19.25
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The New AmsterdamPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$26.75
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The New AmsterdamPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$34.25
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The New AmsterdamPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$47.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The Off-BroadwayTraditional pizza w/ Italian sausage, mushroom, green bellpepper, and yellow onion...Paul’s Specialty Pizzas$16.00
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
Specialty Pizzas
The Off-BroadwayPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$18.25
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The Off-BroadwayPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$25.75
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The Off-BroadwayPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$33.25
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The Off-BroadwayPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$47.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
The B.L.TPaul’s Specialty Pizzas$47.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu

Entrees & Pasta

Beef LasagnaLightly seasoned ground beef, ricotta, marinara, and mozzarella layered between lasagna noodles with parsley & romanoEntrees & Pasta$18.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu

Garlic Bread & Garlic Knots

Garlic Bread(2)Garlic Bread & Garlic Knots$4.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
Optional Add-ons: With cheese +
Dinner Breads(3)Garlic Bread & Garlic Knots$2.22
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu

Appetizers

AppetizerWings available in: Buffalo Sauce, BBQ, Thai, or Plain Served with your choice of dressingAppetizers$14.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
Optional Add-ons: Add French fries for only, Add onion rings for only

Wings & Tenders

AppetizerWings & Tenders$8.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu
AppetizerWings & Tenders$14.99
not listed on 15 other menus; not read on 1 menu

Salads

Antipasto Salad(Large)Spring mix with artichoke hearts, black olives, mushrooms, sharp provolone, salami, pepperoni, sun-dried tomatoes, red onions, grape tomato, and romano.DoorDash$21.58
not listed on 14 other menus; not read on 1 menuDoorDash Storefront (order.online) $21.58
Salads

Specialty Pizzas

The B.L.T.Ranch-based pizza w/ Bacon, Leafy green spinach, & Tomato.no price observed on any surface
not listed on 16 other menus; not read on 1 menu
Specialty Pizzas
May be the same dish as “The B.L.T”.

Paul’s Live from New York Pizza website technology

paulslfnypizza.com was first registered on August 3, 2021. Its registrar is GoDaddy.com, LLC, and GoDaddy manages its DNS.

Protocols: HTTP/2.

DNSSEC was not enabled when observed.

View technology, DNS, network and security evidence
View mail records and evidence

Mail records: Nothing observed in this category.

Site files, feeds and links

View apps, provider accounts and technical evidence

App store details: Nothing observed in this category.

Publisher files

Nothing observed in this category.

Feeds

Nothing observed in this category.

GitHub

Nothing observed in this category.

Additional site intelligence

Sources

Last checked Nov 17, 2026, 7:41 PM UTC. Every fact above names its source when opened; the whole record is in the JSON record, reusable under CC BY 4.0.

Not on file yet: ordering links, legal entity, email.

Sources & updates
How this name was decided

the site's published name — stated on paulslfnypizza.com, abc.ca.gov, facebook.com

Profile sources
Last observed
Nov 17, 2026, 7:41 PM UTCCurrent
Record last changed
Nov 17, 2026, 7:41 PM UTC
First recorded
Nov 17, 2026, 7:41 PM UTC
Observations
447
Sources read
28 of 28