Olde City logo
American4 locations in New York

In its own words: “Olde City serves authentic cheesesteaks, craft beer and cocktails in New York, NY.”

Olde City people and owners

Evan Steinfounder

Roles

Stated by 1 source

Published by the company · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:36 PM UTC

Sarah Beling
  • As printed In addition to my work as Lifestyle Editor at W42ST where I write feature-length reported pieces, interviews and our weekly culture and events newsletter, I’m a contributing writer at The Kitchn, Airport Experience News, Your Brooklyn Guide and the Catskill Mountain Foundation Guide.

    Published by a third-party source · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:36 PM UTC · w42st.com

Stated by 1 source

Published by a third-party source · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:36 PM UTC

Contact Olde City

Emails

events@loveoldecity.com

Email events@loveoldecity.com for reservations.

Published by the company · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:36 PM UTC · loveoldecity.com

Contact forms

Contact form: about:blank

Directly observed · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:37 PM UTC · loveoldecity.com

Contact form: https://www.loveoldecity.com/

Directly observed · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:36 PM UTC · loveoldecity.com

Private dining inquiry: https://www.loveoldecity.com/flyers-hockey/

Directly observed · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:36 PM UTC · loveoldecity.com

Contact form: https://www.loveoldecity.com/contact/

Directly observed · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:35 PM UTC · loveoldecity.com

Private dining inquiry: https://www.loveoldecity.com/private-events-venue/private-room-ues/

Directly observed · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:37 PM UTC · loveoldecity.com

Private dining inquiry: https://www.loveoldecity.com/inquire-now/

Directly observed · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:36 PM UTC · loveoldecity.com

Private dining inquiry: https://www.loveoldecity.com/private-events-venue/main-dining-bar-all-occasions/

Directly observed · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:36 PM UTC · loveoldecity.com

Job application: https://www.loveoldecity.com/jobs

Directly observed · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:37 PM UTC · loveoldecity.com

Private dining inquiry: https://www.loveoldecity.com/sixers/

Directly observed · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:37 PM UTC · loveoldecity.com

Full contact-form data (JSON)

Olde City locations

Olde City has 4 known locations in New York, including New York.

Loading location map…

Liquor licence on file for 3 of 4 stores, all current.

  • 66 Madison AvenueLiquor licence 0340-22-110465, in force when read66 Madison Ave, New York, NY, 10016Run by OC 66 MADISON LLC
  • New YorkLiquor licence 0340-25-116250, in force when read1664 3rd Ave, NY, 10128Run by OC 1664 Third Ave LLC
  • New YorkLiquor licence 0340-22-112300, in force when read576 9th Ave, NY, 10036Run by 576 9TH AVE LLC
  • New York201 Amsterdam Ave, NY, 10023

Olde City menu and prices

Menu at Olde City

232 menu items, including Garlic Battered Cheddar Bites, Real Deal Philly Pretzel and Yuengling Rings.

Online ordering prices: Garlic Battered Cheddar Bites: $14.00 on Toast; Real Deal Philly Pretzel: $9.00 on Uber Eats.

Median price difference versus the website menu. At Olde City, 201 Amsterdam Ave.
Menu sourceMedian differenceMatched items
Toast0%8
Uber Eats7.9%9
Pricing details

Every channel: Natural Wines does not resolve to this place, so this is a difference against its published prices rather than what this branch charges directly. The site prices this dish differently on two of its own menus. No evidence ties this menu to the selected location. Read from this location's own store object. 17 items excluded from matching.

  • Channel prices at Olde City, 201 Amsterdam Ave
    • Toast vs the site's own menu

      item differences 0% to +11.1%; 134 the site's own menu items unmatched

    • Uber Eats vs the site's own menu

      item differences 0% to +15.8%; 133 the site's own menu items unmatched

    the site's own menu: 270 items (66 priced) · Toast: 84 items (79 priced) · Uber Eats: 83 items (57 priced)

    • Toastmenu read · 4/4 locations
    • Grubhubsearch incomplete · 0/4 locations
    • Uber Eatsmenu read · 1/4 locations
    • SpotHoppersearched, not found · 0/4 locations
    • ezCaterlinked · 1/4 locations

    Derived from observations · confirmed Oct 4, 2026, 1:38 PM UTC

Dishes and prices

Resolved for Olde City. 232 dishes across 25 menus; the first 12 are shown here.

Natural Wines, OC UES Reserve Menu, Food, Cocktails, Beer, Cheesesteaks, Seasonal Cocktails, Crispy Chicken Sandwiches, Happy Hour & Nightly Specials, Lunch Special, Classic Hoagies, Olde City Specialties, Philly Phlat Wraps, Philly-Style Specialties (10/04/2024), Philly-Style Specialties (Copy 2/22/23), Pork Roll & Cooper Sharp, Smash Burger, Snacks from Scratch, Specials, Starters (10/04/2024), Vegetarian, Veggie — not confirmed as this location's menu

Natural Wines

Charles & Charles, “Bolt” Cabernet Sauvignon 2021, Columbia ValleyNone$15.00
not listed on 24 other menus
Charles & Charles, “Bolt” Cabernet Sauvignon 2021, Columbia Valley$50.00
not listed on 24 other menus

Food

Cheesesteaks (10oz) - Served on fresh, handmade rolls delivered daily

BuffaloHot or Mild; Blue Cheese or RanchToast$18.00
not listed on 24 other menus
Cheesesteaks (10oz) - Served on fresh, handmade rolls delivered daily
May be the same dish as “Buffalo”.
May be the same dish as “Buffalo”.
May be the same dish as “Roasted Buffalo Cauliflower”.
May be the same dish as “buffalo cauliflower bites”.

Philly Phlat Wraps

BuffaloHot or mild, blue cheese or ranch, romaine, tomato, cheddarPhilly Phlat Wraps$16.00
not listed on 24 other menus
May be the same dish as “Buffalo”.
May be the same dish as “Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls - 20pc”.
May be the same dish as “Buffalo Cutlet”.
May be the same dish as “Hot Buffalo Sauce - Side”.
May be the same dish as “Mild Buffalo Sauce - Side”.
May be the same dish as “Buffalo”.
May be the same dish as “Roasted Buffalo Cauliflower”.
May be the same dish as “buffalo cauliflower bites”.

Tuesday

$28 Corona Buckets(5) Corona Bottlesno price observed on any surface
not listed on 25 other menus
Tuesday · Weekend Specials
May be the same dish as “Corona”.
$10 Lobos 1707 Tequila Shotsno price observed on any surface
not listed on 25 other menus
Tuesday
$12 Lobos 1707 Margaritasno price observed on any surface
not listed on 25 other menus
Tuesday
May be the same dish as “Margarita”.

Wednesday

$28 Heineken Buckets(5) Heineken Bottlesno price observed on any surface
not listed on 25 other menus
Wednesday
May be the same dish as “Heineken”.
May be the same dish as “Heineken 00”.

Featured items

BuffaloHot or Mild; Blue Cheese or RanchUber Eats$21.00
not listed on 24 other menus
Featured items · Cheesesteaks (10oz) - Served on Fresh Baked Philly Hoagie Rolls
May be the same dish as “Buffalo”.
May be the same dish as “Buffalo”.
May be the same dish as “Roasted Buffalo Cauliflower”.
May be the same dish as “buffalo cauliflower bites”.

Thursday

$11 Roseno price observed on any surface
not listed on 25 other menus
Thursday
$28 Modelo Buckets(5) Modelo Especial Bottlesno price observed on any surface
not listed on 25 other menus
Thursday
May be the same dish as “Modelo”.

Friday

$30 NUTRL Seltzer Buckets(5) NUTRL Seltzers; Pineapple, Watermelon, Mango or Raspberryno price observed on any surface
not listed on 25 other menus
Friday
May be the same dish as “Nutrl Seltzer”.
Show 1 more dish

The menus read print no prices.

Weekend Specials

$25 Bud Light Bucket(5) Bud Light Bottles
not listed on 25 other menus
Weekend Specials
May be the same dish as “Bud Light”.

Olde City website technology

Appears to use React.

loveoldecity.com was first registered on June 30, 2021. Its registrar is GoDaddy.com, LLC, and GoDaddy manages its DNS.

Protocols: HTTP/2.

DNSSEC was not enabled when observed.

SPF authorizes dc-aa8e722993._spfm.loveoldecity.com.

SPF is configured. DMARC requests neither quarantine nor rejection (p=none).

View technology, DNS, network and security evidence
View mail records and evidence

Site files, feeds and links

View apps, provider accounts and technical evidence

App store details: Nothing observed in this category.

Publisher files

Nothing observed in this category.

Feeds

Nothing observed in this category.

GitHub

Nothing observed in this category.

Additional site intelligence

Sources

Last checked Oct 4, 2026, 1:38 PM UTC. Every fact above names its source when opened; the whole record is in the JSON record, reusable under CC BY 4.0.

Not on file yet: ordering links.

Sources & updates
How this name was decided

the site's published name — stated on loveoldecity.com, data.ny.gov, facebook.com

Names weighed and not chosen

Profile sources
Last observed
Oct 4, 2026, 1:38 PM UTCStale
Record last changed
Oct 4, 2026, 1:38 PM UTC
First recorded
Oct 4, 2026, 1:39 PM UTC
Observations
1,548
Sources read
26 of 26