Costello's Pizza logo

Costello's Pizza

pizza3 locations in New Jersey

In its own words: “Welcome to Costellos Pizza with three convienant locations in South Jersey."”

Contact Costello's Pizza

Costello's Pizza jobs

Careers page
Hiring evidence

Costello's Pizza locations

Costello's Pizza has 3 known locations in New Jersey, including Galloway and Hammonton.

Loading location map…
  • Costello's at the Nest421 Chris Gaupp Dr, Galloway, NJ, 08205
  • Costello's Pizzeria & Wings (Hammonton)30 N White Horse Pike, Hammonton, NJ, 08037
  • Costello's Pizzeria & Wings (Smithville)45 S New York Rd, Unit 205-207, Galloway, NJ, 08205

Costello's Pizza menu and prices

Menu at Costello's Pizzeria & Wings (Hammonton)

301 menu items, including Hot Veggie App Sampler, Italian Long Hot Burger and Garden Salad.

Pricing details
  • Channel prices at Costello's Pizzeria & Wings (Hammonton), 30 N White Horse Pike
    • Grubhub vs the site's own menu0%

      median over 3 matched items (0% to 0%); 10 the site's own menu items unmatched

    • Slice vs the site's own menu0%

      median over 3 matched items (0% to 0%); 10 the site's own menu items unmatched

    • Uber Eats vs the site's own menu+20.0%

      median over 4 matched items (+20.0% to +20.0%); 9 the site's own menu items unmatched

    the site's own menu: 18 items (14 priced) · Grubhub: 240 items (209 priced) · Slice: 137 items (136 priced) · Uber Eats: 115 items (115 priced)

    • Grubhubmenu read · 2/3 locations
    • Uber Eatsmenu read · 3/3 locations
    • Slicemenu read · 3/3 locations
    • SpotHoppersearch confirmed · 0/3 locations

    Derived from observations · confirmed Nov 11, 2026, 3:38 PM UTC

Online ordering prices: Hot Veggie App Sampler: $18.99 on Grubhub; Italian Long Hot Burger: $14.99 on Grubhub.

Dishes and prices

Resolved for Costello's Pizzeria & Wings (Hammonton). 301 dishes across 6 menus; the first 12 are shown here.

MENU (PDF) — not confirmed as this location's menu

Compared against MENU (PDF).

MENU (PDF)

Jalapeño Poppers

6 Pieces $10.49, 12 Pieces $17.49, 24 Pieces$29.49
not listed on 3 other menusMENU (PDF) $29.49MENU (PDF) $29.49
Jalapeño Poppers · Jalapeño Poppers Fried jalapeños stuffed with cream cheese and bacon served with raspberry

$9.49 Broccoli florets, cheddar cheese & bacon battered & fried served

Mozzarella Sticks Fried mozzarella served with homemade marinara 6 Piece $9.49,12 Piece $15.99,24 Piece$20.99
not listed on 5 other menus
Mozzarella Sticks · $9.49 Broccoli florets, cheddar cheese & bacon battered & fried served
Mozzarella Sticks Fried mozzarella served with homemade marinara 6 Piece $9.49,12 Piece $15.99, 24 PieceMENU (PDF)$20.99
not listed on 5 other menus

Appetizers

Hot Veggie App Sampler4 Mac & cheese bites, 3 mozzarella sticks, 3 broccoli bite & 3 jalapeño poppers. Served with a side of marinara & ranch.MENU (PDF)$18.99
MENU (PDF) not listed on this menuMENU (PDF) not listed on this menuGrubhub $18.99Slice $18.99Uber Eats $22.79
Appetizers · Appetizers & Sides · Cold Veggie App Sampler

Appetizers

Asiago Wild Mushroom Arancini2 Italian rice balls filled with wild mushroom and creamy asiago cheese. Served witha side of vodka sauce.Slice$10.99
not listed on 4 other menusUber Eats $13.19
Appetizers · Appetizers & Sides
Meatball App4 Meatballs topped with whipped ricotta cheese & homemade marinara sauce.Grubhub$13.99
not listed on 3 other menusSlice $11.99Uber Eats $16.79
Appetizers · Appetizers & Sides
Spinach and Artichoke DipServed with tortilla chips.Grubhub$12.99sold out
not listed on 5 other menus
Appetizers

Salads

Chopped Italian AntipastoA bed of mixed greens, chopped italian meats, olives, roasted peppers & sharp provolone cheese.Grubhub$13.99
not listed on 3 other menusSlice $13.99Uber Eats $16.79
Salads

Chicken Sandwiches

Alabama BBQ ChickenBlackened chicken topped with alabama bbq sauce and sliced cheddar cheese served on a brioche bun.Grubhub$12.99
not listed on 3 other menusSlice $12.99Uber Eats $15.59
Chicken Sandwiches
May be the same dish as “Alabama BBQ Chicken”.
May be the same dish as “BBQ Chicken Sandwich”.
May be the same dish as “Alabama BBQ Chicken Sandwich”.

Specialty Cold Subs

Arugula and Fresh BurrataArugula, burrata cheese, blistered tomatoes and balsamic glaze. Served on a ciabatta roll.Slice$12.99
not listed on 4 other menusUber Eats $15.59
Specialty Cold Subs
Arugula and fresh BurarataArugula, burrata cheese, blisterd tomatoes and balsamic glaze. Served on a cciabatta. try with chicken cutlet or breaded eggplant.Grubhub$12.99
not listed on 5 other menus
Specialty Cold Subs

Pasta (Archived)

Pasta Alfredo with Chicken and BroccoliComes with grilled chicken and broccoli in an Alfredo sauce.Grubhub$20.99sold out
not listed on 5 other menus
Pasta (Archived)
Show 1 more dish

Beverages (Archived)

AquafinaPure water for a perfect taste. Add a refreshing water to your meal.Grubhub$4.50sold out
not listed on 5 other menus
Beverages (Archived)
Grubhub lists prices the same as the website menu over 3 dishes, at Costello's Pizzeria & Wings (Hammonton), 30 N White Horse Pike
MENU (PDF) does not resolve to this place, so this is a difference against its published prices rather than what this branch charges directly
Slice lists prices the same as the website menu over 3 dishes, at Costello's Pizzeria & Wings (Hammonton), 30 N White Horse Pike
MENU (PDF) does not resolve to this place, so this is a difference against its published prices rather than what this branch charges directly
Uber Eats lists prices a median 20% above the website menu over 4 dishes, at Costello's Pizzeria & Wings (Hammonton), 30 N White Horse Pike
MENU (PDF) does not resolve to this place, so this is a difference against its published prices rather than what this branch charges directly

Costello's Pizza website technology

Web stack: PHP. Google Analytics 4 (GA4; website analytics).

costellospizza.com was first registered on July 16, 2009. Its registrar is GoDaddy.com, LLC.

Protocols: TLS 1.3 and HTTP/2.

HTTPS certificate: Let's Encrypt, expires December 23, 2026.

DNSSEC was not enabled when observed.

SPF is configured with a hard fail (-all). DMARC requests neither quarantine nor rejection (p=none).

View technology, DNS, network and security evidence
View mail records and evidence

Site files, feeds and links

View apps, provider accounts and technical evidence

App store details: Nothing observed in this category.

Publisher files

Nothing observed in this category.

Feeds

Nothing observed in this category.

GitHub

Nothing observed in this category.

Additional site intelligence

Sources

Last checked Nov 11, 2026, 3:38 PM UTC. Every fact above names its source when opened; the whole record is in the JSON record, reusable under CC BY 4.0.

Not on file yet: ordering links, legal entity, owners, email.

Sources & updates
How this name was decided

the site's published name — stated on costellospizza.com, instagram.com

Profile sources
Last observed
Nov 11, 2026, 3:38 PM UTCRecent
Record last changed
Nov 11, 2026, 3:38 PM UTC
First recorded
Nov 11, 2026, 3:38 PM UTC
Observations
158
Sources read
28 of 28